Q1FY27 margin miss (2.9% UCP vs 8-8.5% prior target) forced a reset to 6.5%+ floor.
- Q2 margin blow out — answer hedged.
- Channel inventory normalization current — answer hedged.
Three questions: (1) Given import costs, copper up 9% sequentially, and tepid volumes, could Q2 margins be even more negative and the 6.5% full year Segment II EBIT guidance see further tapering? (2) On the trade schemes - was it direct discounting and how difficult will it be to roll back these discounts? (3) Is the data center MEP business margin accretive or just a top-line story?
I'll answer the last one first. The data center business is not a top-line alone, out of the MEP project verticals, if you take buildings or the infra projects like Metro Rail or electrical water, compared with that, the data center segment is attractive for the simple reason these are 8-month to 12-months commissioning projects, it doesn't last 3-4 years. The second thing is, the payment terms are very favourable. Third is, there are enough price escalation provisions on the metal prices, specifically, and on electrical items, so we are we are very happy with the MEP projects. Therefore, we are we I may not say that we are being given a premium or something like that, but we are the preferred contractors, it is compared with other segments, it is very attractive, so it is not a top-line story alone, it is a highly profitable business with good cash flows. Come to the room air conditioners, you are right, the Blue Star would like to be in that high-end premium segment. Our behavior would have been like that had it not been for the unprecedented increase in the input costs, and our behavior would have been different if it is not the year after a bad summer year. This consumer finance cost had significantly gone up, but it paid off, and we saw in the 15 days in May when we took that decision, our reversing the whole trend and gaining 10 basis points market share. In June, even though the summer ended, we ended up gaining around 50 basis points market share. I do not foresee in Q2 anything dramatically going to change in terms of the cost structure, input costs are going to be higher only. What I am expecting is the market operating prices should be better than what it is. We are determined; we will get back to our conventional margins in Q4. Our outlook, I had said that once upon a time it was a 12% margin industry and it came down to 9.5% to 10%, it came down to 8% to 8.5%, off late I have been saying with the capacity that has increased, and intense competition, and the entry-level buyers driving the growth, it more looks like 7.5% to 8%. I'm only hoping that, it should go back to 7.5% to 8%. Whether it will be 7% or 7.5%, we are unable to state.
Are channel inventory levels normalized? At what level are they currently?
I don't think it is in alarming level, but it has not normalized. The anticipation was the summer will continue beyond June into July, that was the expectation. But June itself, after 10th it suddenly collapsed the demand. Therefore, the channels carry some more inventory, but I don't think it is an alarming level at all. The key question to be asked is that, when the channel will start buying the new inventory for the forthcoming festival season, I think in Kerala, it'll start just before Onam, rest of it during the Ganesh Chaturthi period onwards. This this month is going to be a lull. There is a lot of confusion with regard to the, when you say, there are the brands who hold the stocks in the field in their warehouses, then the trade have already bought it and they are selling it during the month. If you put together, my estimate is it will be 60 days should be normal and if you take the trade alone, 45 days should be normal.
On RAC margins revival: what is the deferred cost impact from Q4, and what are the other initiatives to revive Unitary Products margins for rest of FY27? Also, on the MEP business - earlier guidance was 8-10% revenue growth for FY27. Are you upgrading guidance given the strong data center performance?
There is no deferred cost from Q4 at all because you mentioned something like what is the deferred cost. The margin that we declared in Q4 is the right margin. Now it was a double-digit margin, if you recollect, okay? and there is no deferred cost into Q1 it is an actual cost that was incurred in Q4. How it has to be understood is that when you do the material accounting, it is on a rolling basis. So you will have an inventory of some old material also being there and as you move into the season, there will be a fresh material that will be coming in. The price increase that is to be passed on has not been passed on fully, that is the first part of it. Unfortunately, it did not change because many of our competitors had material, and they were maintaining lower prices. In the process, having understood that we lost a 50 basis point market share in April, what we should be doing is that our tertiary sales should be improved through consumer finance and other schemes so that the dealers are able to liquidate, so we incurred those costs. These costs came in May and June in a significant manner, which resulted in our bouncing back with a 10 basis point market share in tertiary sales. A gain, in June, I think we performed exceedingly well in the industry with a 50 basis point gain market share. So the margin that is declared is not due to any deferred costs and all, it's an actual margin that is what has taken place. Hopefully, old inventory across industry is getting exhausted, the market operating prices one hopes will go up and the second part is, fortunately it is a lean season. The second quarter is not a quarter, it will pick up from Onam season, Ganpati onwards towards the festival season. So the third part of the exercise is by Q4, we should have rejigged our product portfolio. Our calculation with the cost saving opportunities that we have got and our view of the market. I'm saying that 6.5% for full year may not be a challenge and we have to look at 7% to 7.5%. On MEP: I had indicated the CAGR for the room air conditioners as a category for the industry, over a 5-year period, 18% is looking good. I had also stated commercial air conditioner of the MEP projects in terms of CAGR, you should look at only 8% to 10% kind of growth. But what has significantly changed is the data center segment, where there is a huge rush to block the capacities of the vendors. Probably, the growth what we indicated as 8% to 10% may go up to 12% for a couple of years. This financial year, you can take that our order inflow will be Rs.3,000 Crore, and our revenue will be Rs.1,350 Crore from segment alone. This is likely to become an order inflow of around Rs.4,500 Crore next year and around Rs.2,100 Crore of revenue next year.
Three questions: (1) On commercial refrigeration - was the degrowth industry-wide demand destruction or specific market share loss due to competition? (2) Can Segment I margins structurally reach north of 8-8.5% as data center mix increases? (3) Can you split the UCP volume and value growth for Q1?
We have held on to our market share, there is absolutely no problem. Unlike, room air conditioners where you have a GFK data, we do not have, we have to go by industry data that is available, that business is through predominantly through the OEMs. I don't think there is a residential market of significant size. We know which are the rate contracts whether it is Amul or Mother Dairy or Havmor, so many ice cream brands what they are lifting from there. This is a, this is not a market share loss, the industry has not grown, and that's why we are hopeful at some point of time it has to revive. On Segment I margins: Certainly, as we move towards that peak, golden period of data center-dominated MEP segment, the margin should go up. On volume/value growth: My estimate is in Q1, room air conditioners market in volume terms grew by 21% is my estimate, and Blue Star grew by 18%. In revenue terms, the market grew by 25%, and Blue Star grew by 21%. These are all on the primary sales basis. You are seeing the revenue growth as 13% because commercial refrigeration has pulled it down. In secondary sales, Blue Star lost a market share of 30 bps compared with March or compared with FY26, which is 0.3% drop in tertiary sales. In the primary sales, because of that April huge dip, Blue Star lost 0.65% or 65 bps.
On commercial AC: what was the growth in Q1 and what is the outlook? Also, what capex was done in Q1 and what is planned for the next 9 months?
Commercial AC space, is driven by today the manufacturing or industrial sector, which is doing well, data center chillers market is growing, while we have a 30% market share in data center MEP projects, and our market share will be 10% to 12% in data center chillers, because we compete with larger four or five multinational players and there the market share is not 30%. If you look at manufacturing, if you look at the other sector which had driven growth is the healthcare sector, the other sector which is also doing well is the education sector. The outlook will be that around 10% growth is easily possible in commercial air conditioning, and 15% I am not able to predict now.
What capex was done in Q1 and how much is planned for the next 9 months?
In Q1, the capex has been in the region of around Rs.60 Crore to Rs.70 Crore. And annually, if you see, our capex, when I say capex, it includes capex, it includes R&D intangibles spends, if any, on product development as well as, you know, any digital spends that we do, overall, the growth-related spend should be in the region of around Rs.300 Crore to Rs.350 Crore if everything goes as per plan.
You attempted to pass on part of the cost surge but kept prices in tandem with the market at about 5%. How much price hike is required to recoup the lost margins from here on?
I strictly speaking, even in the month of May, 8% more was needed. Yesterday, the copper has touched record price, I don't know today what it is. The rupee is still volatile, and the petroleum-based products prices will keep going up. Ideally you pass on additional 8%, but that is not going to be available, it all depends on how the market is going to behave. So, you have to go ahead and reduce the cost. There is no other go. I don't think market will be accepting it.
Given we increased prices only in line with the industry at around 5%, what led to the market share loss? And what does product rejig entail? Are we confident it can be completed by Q3 to benefit from the festive season and Q4?
The first part is that, I don't think there were many brands had increased it even by 5%. The prices were, the products at older prices were available even in the month of June. Despite being a good summer, so that means products have been manufactured, the people who strategically bought the commodities, knowing that it is going up, and they were able to operate with 3.5% to 4% margin. It is not that even that 5% was passed on by the other brands. We had many brands who had not even increased it by 5%. The second part is that Blue Star's own thing could have been that, had we known, we would have reengineered the products. What should have been different in retrospective is that all that it is needed is the lowest cost entry-level products, predominantly, 90% has to be that. Now, your question is whether in 6 months it can be done? It can be done, there is no problem. There are quite a few levers have to be used, the alternate makes of the components, some portfolio we may have to outsource, in certain other cases, the products will have to be redesigned. We have already plans to cut down some of the models and replace it with cost competitive models. What will not change is, we are very clear in terms of brand positioning, it has to be durable products, it has to be highly reliable products, it should be differentiated. Within that element, we have to compete on price as well. It is not that we will go down the path of cheap products, which is not the idea at all, but we have enough levers.
On exports: what is the current export run rate, how does FY27 look, and what is the opportunity in US and Europe? The USD100 million additional target for FY28 - is it only US?
There are 3 distinct markets. There is our traditional Middle East, Africa market, which is muted for obvious reasons, that we have to wait for this crisis to be over. The most profitable market for air conditioning industry is North America, that is the most profitable market for any brand and then comes Europe. The 2 products that we are pursuing are air-to-air heat pump, air-to-water heat pump. And these are to replace the conventional heating systems out there. U.S. is beginning to move in the direction that too with the new refrigerants and we were also very clear we won't directly enter in our brand, which is an expensive proposition, profitable opportunity is manufacturing products for other brands there under a CDM route. CDM is custom, design and manufacturing, which means your brand in U.S. has decided that I won't introduce these, these models, these features, and you custom design for them, and you manufacture and export. This process takes a long time, With a couple of customers, we have progressed. Our shipments are taking place. Trial order has completed 2 seasons of summer and winter now, it is on the verge of scaling. There, this complication over the past 12 months of which tariff, there is a derivative tariff, there is suddenly 100% free trade agreement is hanging. Despite that, we have done that revenue figure, and as we continue, the shipments are beginning to take place, all are waiting for when this trade-related issues will get resolved, that's where US is. It is not scaling now, only for that reason, otherwise they are, the customers are desperate to get this product, it is a huge success there. In both US and Europe, we are seen as China Plus One. Food news, the learning curve is over, these products are perfected, these products are working. We hope this tariff thing cannot linger for a long time, and we should be growing.
USD100 million is going to be additional revenue over and above FY26 exports in FY28?
Yes, coming to, in case if you wanted to know the export numbers, in the current year, the rupee has moved, so taking an average, you can put it at around USD80 million to USD85 million in the current FY26, the reported year, last year. And year before that, it would have been in the region of around USD55 million to USD60 million. So, around last year growth will be around 40% in exports. Yes, additional over FY26 and by FY28.
In Q4, you indicated roughly 5% BEE-rating price hike plus another 8% on commodity inflation. But Q1 price action seems to be around 3-4%. Is this gap largely due to discounting? And how are we looking at ASP increases for the next three quarters?
No, your understanding is only partially right. The 5 plus 8 that is 13 is supposed to be passed on, we could succeed in passing on only around 5, some models 3, some models 4, some models 5. We failed or it was not possible for us to pass on the rest at all. This is in terms of the gross margin. Then you have got the operating costs that are there, what happens is when you are pushing the tertiary sale, you are going to be incurring costs in consumer finance and other costs, in-shop promotions, advertising. So, the combined effect is resulting in a margin erosion, this what it is. So balance 8 is not passed on. The month of July-August is not a big one, the September it should pick up, and only when sale is there you can adjust the margin. I see only a marginal improvement happening in Q2. Q3 will be, assuming the festival season does well, it should be doing well. Q4 should be doing well because by then we will be ready with many new other cost saving in the product or the cost take-out from the products, or a new portfolio, a mix of what we may outsource and what we will make ourselves. I had stated that I am able to disclose that 6.5% is possible full year. Our aspiration is 7.5%. So, 7% or 7.5% we have to wait and see how we progress each quarter. Structurally, the unfortunate part will be if it is to drop to 6.5% industry. I don't think it will happen given that the 18% growth CAGR is going to take place. This industry at this stage going by what all has happened in television or washing machines or refrigerator, I think it will hold on to 7% to 7.5%.